MDG pictograms

The Millennium Development Goals

One year ago, wearing another hat, I attended the UN’s ‘Advance Global Health – Achieve the MDGs’ conference in Melbourne.

The forum is held annually – it is a means by which the UN takes the global pulse to see what issues it should focus on.

The conference was huge by Australian standards, with 1,500 delegates in attendance, most of them representing NGOs from around the world, delivering services to reduce infant mortality, improve maternal health, improve schooling, and so on. The UN wanted to hear how things are progressing.

Generally the news is good, and in some countries it is exceptionally good. The MDG (Millenium Development Goal) benchmarks won’t all be reached by 2015, but the world is definitely trending in the right direction. One dramatic example: The number of people living on $1.25 a day or less in Vietnam fell from 64% to just 22% in thirteen years.

Clearly there is a place for well-resourced development organisations, but they have to know when to step back, too. My abiding memory of the conference was Elena Jeffreys of the Scarlet Alliance. She drew attention to the fact that there can sometimes be a cluttered NGO ‘marketplace’ and the better-known, better-resourced organisations can suck all the oxygen out of it – taking up the media and funding opportunities. The problem, she said, is that they are often self-appointed, yet their voices are being heard at the expense of the more representative but less savvy local organisations. The largest union in Cambodia is the home-grown Women’s Network for Unity. If you’ve ever heard of it, you have done well. There are over 1,000 NGOs working in Cambodia and it is always easier to get media comment from native English speakers.

Ms Jeffreys goes further than that and suggests that rich-world NGOs will often come in and start lobbying in a fashion that is actually counterproductive to existing local efforts. She summed up:

Give us our rights; we can do the rest.

Dr. Claudio Schuftan of the People’s Health Movement echoed her sentiments. He said people in developing nations should not be seen as mere beneficiaries. “Rather,” he said,

we are mobilising rights holders to make their own claims.

This message could be challenging for the relief and development industry. At some level they generally see their organisations as needing to persist indefinitely into the future. Their work will remain necessary, but it will be capable of being done by local organisations and that is infinitely more desirable than having rich outsiders swoop in to resolve problems.

The adjustment could be difficult. It’s exciting and pleasant-sounding to expand to a new country; harder to announce that you are withdrawing from one. Almost sounds like a failure. Yet that is what needs to be done, sooner or later.

The way of the future can be seen in countries such as Chile and Malaysia, which have reached a medium level of wealth per capita and have fewer outside relief agencies operating there. Their neighbours Indonesia and Peru, however, retain a mindset that outsiders should come in and help. We are right at the point where many countries are switching from the latter to the former mentality.

Making Progress on the MDGs

See which countries have made the most progress by clicking on the map above. Image by Gates Foundation via Flickr

Related post:

More from the blogosphere (no endorsement implied):


This video formed part of the opening of last year’s conference

  1. […] NGOs: Job well done, but don’t overstay your welcome […]

  2. mspbwatch says:

    Reblogged this on MSPB Watch and commented:
    This is relevant to the problems afflicting the federal whistleblower community. NGOs there should take note.

  3. […] NGOs: Job well done, but don’t overstay your welcome 30 August 2011 […]

  4. […] organisations to develop the capacity to do it themselves. That’s fine as long as there is a real plan to hand over but I’ve not heard that there is one, only a hope that it will be possible at some point in […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s